1910-1920s Deputy Marshal badge

Item Description:

A vintage Deputy Marshal badge featuring:

• Raised five-pointed star in center.
• Arched “DEPUTY” and “MARSHAL” lettering surrounding the star.
• Spread-wing eagle at the top with a ribbon in its beak.
• Vertical pinback with C-catch, typical of early 20th-century law enforcement badges.
• Constructed from what appears to be nickel silver (German silver) or another silver-tone alloy.
• Dimensions: ~2-3/8" H x 1-3/4" W.
• Weight: ~25 grams.

Historical Context:

Badges of this style were commonly used in the early 1900s, especially in rural sheriff's departments and U.S. marshals’ offices across the western and southern United States. The eagle and star motif was typical for U.S. law enforcement insignia. The pin style suggests pre-1940s design, consistent with your estimate of 1910–1920.

The “Deputy Marshal” title could pertain to U.S. Marshals Service or local/county marshal positions—exact provenance would increase value significantly, especially if it can be linked to a specific jurisdiction or historical figure.

Condition:

• Excellent vintage condition with visible aging and patina.
• Original hardware intact, including period-correct C-clasp, which boosts authenticity.
• Surface wear consistent with age but no significant damage.

Estimated Value:

• Retail value (if authenticated): $175–$350 USD
• Auction/private sale: $100–$250 USD, depending on provenance and buyer interest
• Provenance effect: If tied to a notable law enforcement figure or specific marshal's office, the value could exceed $500.

Recommendation:

• You may wish to have it professionally appraised for authentication (e.g., by a law enforcement memorabilia specialist or historical arms/militaria expert).
• If considering resale, target collectors of Old West memorabilia, law enforcement history, or military crossover items (since your great-grandfather was Navy).
• Ensure clear photographs and provenance notes accompany any listings.