Skip to main content

Antique Pie Safe

G
15 years ago
AI Appraisal
Description I don't really know anything about this piece. I have had it a long time and just found out that is a pie safe. I would love to find out something more.
Category General Antiques and Collectibles
Condition Excellent
Size and dimensions of this item approx 6' tall and 4' wide
Weight Very Heavy
Price Paid (If known) $1800 in the 1980s at an antique store
Want more from your appraisals?

Upgrade for PDF reports, more daily appraisals, and ad-free experience.

View Plans →

Submitted by Lovejoy

Hard to tell from the images if this one actually started out as a pie safe or was a later conversion of an existing cupboard. Pie safes were a hot decorator item in the 1980's and demand often exceed supply, I converted a lot of damaged cabinets myself into pie safes ;~). Demand for them now is not what it was, at auction I see them go for for under $500.00

Submitted by Mrsdooley2

I have this same exact pie safe. "Aunt Lizzie", as we call her, is a real pie safe, not converted from anything. I was stunned to find this picture on the Internet and hope I can share a little more information with you. Aunt Lizzie has been in our family for at least 4 generations and according to family lore was made in West Virginia out of pecan. Not sure about the pecan (could be walnut, I suppose) but is extremely heavy and solid. Mine has sold upper doors with the same design as on the lower doors and mine has white china knobs. So I think originally, yours had solid doors. I have no idea of value, but she's priceless to me. I would like to obtain an insurance estimate of value. I never dreamed I'd see another Aunt Lizzie, and having seen yours I now know she was manufactured, not hand made. Thanks for putting the pictures on the internet.

Submitted by MzKitti

Ok first off @MrsDooley2 you posted on my bday thank you very much! lol 

And 2ndly...wow! this is pretty!  i JUST today received a cabinet like this one except my is a lil more plain. The knobs are the original wood ones that match the drawers. And NO designs on doors. Mine appears to be an authentic 'safe' it has the holes on the side panels and all the wood looks original. I wish i had remembered to look at the back more closely before i sat it in the corner where it is gonna live in my room. I am not by any means an expert but i know a tiny bit about what "old/antique" should look like. I this piece! Its so unique to anything i have so far. And to my knowledge no one i know has one! =D I am only 43 but my parents have always had an appreciation for antiques. And until i got older i didnt. I am glad my dad offered and i accepted it!  I am so happy to find such a great array of different versions of "safes"...thanks so much for sharing ladies!

📸 Quick Scan
Garage-Sale Mode Fast appraisals on the go