Malfroy ?

appraisal required

Item Description:

• Medium: Oil on paper.
• Signature: The painting is signed "Malfroy" in the bottom corner.
• Size: Approximately 80 cm x 60 cm.
• Date Period: Circa 1915 (as indicated on the reverse).
• Condition: Fair, with signs of aging. Original framing adds authenticity but may need restoration for preservation.

Analysis of the Artist:

The name "Malfroy" is most likely associated with Charles Malfroy (1862–1918), a French artist known for impressionistic landscapes and maritime themes. If this painting is an authentic work by Charles Malfroy, it would align with his active period and style, though the subject matter here (aerial combat scene) deviates from his usual themes. Further research or expert verification is needed to confirm attribution.

Subject and Historical Context:

The painting depicts an aerial combat scene, likely inspired by World War I, which aligns with the stated date of 1915. This subject matter would have been timely and relevant during the period, potentially adding historical significance. The inscription on the back, "Combat dans le ciel" (French for "Battle in the Sky"), reinforces the theme and possibly indicates the original title.

Condition Assessment:

• The painting appears to have aged naturally, with no significant visible damage or over-painting.
• Original framing supports its authenticity but could benefit from professional conservation.
• The paper medium requires careful handling, as oil on paper is more fragile than oil on canvas.

Estimated Value:

• If Attributed to Charles Malfroy:
  • Depending on authentication, subject matter, and condition, the painting could range between $2,000 and $5,000 USD at auction, as it is an uncommon subject for Malfroy.
• If a Work by Another Artist or Unauthenticated:
  • The value could range between $300 and $1,000 USD, based on its decorative appeal, age, and historical theme.

Recommendations:

1. Professional Authentication:
   • Consult with a reputable art appraiser or auction house to verify the artist’s signature and establish provenance.
   • An expert in early 20th-century French art or World War I-themed works would be ideal.
2. Condition Report and Restoration:
   • Obtain a professional condition report to assess whether the paper or frame needs restoration or conservation.
   • Proper preservation can enhance the painting’s value.
3. Historical Research:
   • Investigate the painting’s history further, as its depiction of aerial combat during World War I adds unique historical interest.